Thomas Scott Executed

ThomasScott

“It cannot be said that Riel was hanged on account of his opinion.  It is equally true that he was not executed for anything connected with the late rebellion.  He was hanged for Scott’s murder; that is the simple truth of it.”   —  Wilfrid Laurier, 1885

An event on March 4, 1870, in Fort Garry (now Winnipeg), is still causing political repercussions in Canada.  Louis Riel had Ontario Orangeman, Thomas Scott, executed in the prison yard at Fort Garry.  The outcry in Ontario was so great that Riel was hanged in Regina in 1885, after leading a rebellion on the prairies.  In Quebec, Riel was regarded as a martyr, and the Conservatives were blamed for his death.

Scott’s trial had been held on March 3, 1870, and was called “a council of war.”  It was presided over by Ambroise Lépine, who was one of Riel’s chief aides.  Riel was the prosecutor and one of the three witnesses who were called.  Scott was not allowed to call any witnesses in his own defence.

The charge against Scott was that he had taken up arms against Riel’s provisional government.  It was “phoney” because dozens of others had done the same thing and had been released.,  Later, Riel told federal mediator Donald A. Smith (Lord Strathcona) the real reason.  It was that Scott had been rough and abusive  to the guards and insulting to Riel himself.

When the time came for the execution on March 4, Scott stood before a wall of the prison and was allowed to pray with Methodist minister Young.  He then knelt in the snow, a coffin beside him.  There were six Métis in the firing party, and they had all been drinking.  Three of their rifles contained blank charges so it would not be known who actually fired the bullets that killed Scott.  After the guns blasted the kneeling Scott, another Métis had to dash up with a revolver and put a bullet through his head because he was only wounded.

The body was buried secretly and its resting place has never been found.  It is rumoured  that the coffin was dropped into the river through a hole in the ice.

To continue reading about Thomas Scott, I suggest the following: CBC’s Execution of Thomas Scott; The Execution of Thomas Scott, written by George Siamandas; Execution of Thomas Scott on Canada: A Country by Consent. To read a book, I recommend The Execution of Thomas Scott. Adventures in Canadian History.

20 comments

  1. I learned about Louis Riel and the Metis from a biography of James J. Hill (by Albro Martin). It was the “half-wild” French-Indian Metis who were the main providers of the Hudson’s Bay Company’s furs which flowed from Ft. Garry down the Red River of the North into Minnesota, to wind up at the Mississippi River port of St. Paul–by 1870 controlled by the enterprising young Canadian farm boy named Jim Hill. All of which inspired Hill to build the St. Paul, Minneapolis & Manitoba Railway (with backing from the Bank of Montreal and “movers and shakers” including Donald A. Smith, Lord Strathcona). Which Hill then extended westward into the Dakota Territory, after developing a hard red winter wheat that could be milled into bread flour. In 1887, he extended his railroad far into Montana, tapping its wealth of resources and enticing farmers to plant wheat in the prairies surrounding the newly expanded railroad. Which then became the Great Northern Railway and reached Seattle and the Puget Sound area just in time for the “great recession” of that era, known as the Panic of 1893.

    James J. Hill’s legacy lives today as the BNSF Railway’s “highline” across the northern tier of the western United States.

    Like

  2. Thank you for visiting my “1870 to 1918” site and especially my blogs on the obscure 1904-1905 Russo-Japanese War. I was interested to read your information. It shows how complex and difficult things were. As a U.S. citizen, I am one in that population who likes to pretend that everything up there is peaceful and friendly. This is a kind of delusion that seems to help us but actually doesn’t: “Why can’t we be as nice as those Canadians?” A bunch of garbage, actually.

    Like

    • We certainly fought for our freedom as well. The past is peppered with acts of ugliness. Thanks for commenting, Jenny. It’s always appreciated! 🙂

      Like

  3. Could I draw attention to the fact that the image is not the correct Thomas Scott. It is an image of the Rev. Thomas Scott who died, peacefully, in 1821.

    Like

Let me know what's on your mind

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.